Medicube Triple Collagen Toner vs TRIPLE COLLAGEN Toner 4.0: which should you buy?
The same collagen toner twice: 2,913 reviews of history versus a newer 4.0 with a wider skin-type brief.
medicube medicube Triple Collagen Toner - Hydrolyzed, Atelo
4.6(2,913) £14.20£15.60-9% Check price on Amazon →
The short answer
if hydration is the goal and you want the version with 2,913 reviews behind it.
if your skin is on the sensitive side or firmness is your main reason for buying.
Links to Amazon.co.uk are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. How this works.
Side by side
| medicube Triple Collagen Toner - Hydrolyzed | medicube TRIPLE COLLAGEN Toner 4.0 | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | £14.20£15.60-9% See on Amazon → | £15.79 See on Amazon → |
| Rating | ★★★★★ 4.6 | ★★★★★ 4.6 |
| Review count | 2,913 | 367 |
| Amazon best-seller rank | #16 in Face Astringents & Toners | #337 in Face Astringents & Toners |
| Amazon purchases | 2K+ bought | 50+ bought |
| Key active | collagen | collagen |
| Format | toner | toner |
| Size | 140ml | 140 ml |
| Routine step | tone | tone |
| Best for | glow | firmness |
| Sensitive-skin friendly | Listing flags no strong actives | Listing flags no strong actives |
| Highlights |
|
|
Our verdict
Same name, same 140ml bottle, same 4.6/5 average, same under-£15 bracket, same collagen hero. On the numbers the only real gap is depth of feedback: the original has 2,913 reviews behind its 4.6, the 4.0 has 367. That makes the original the safer read on consistency. What the 4.0 offers in return is a slightly wider brief. It is listed for sensitive skin as well as dry, combination and normal, and it leads on firmness with hydration second, where the original is framed the other way round. Both are flagged gentle enough for daily use. Tie-breaker: if your skin is on the reactive side, or firmness is the reason you are buying a collagen toner at all, take the 4.0. If hydration is the goal, or you simply want the version thousands of people have already scored, the original holds up and costs no more.
Which one is for you?
- Choose the original Triple Collagen Toner if hydration is the goal and you want the version with 2,913 reviews behind it. Read our full look at the medicube Triple Collagen Toner - Hydrolyzed →
- Choose the Triple Collagen Toner 4.0 if your skin is on the sensitive side or firmness is your main reason for buying. Read our full look at the medicube TRIPLE COLLAGEN Toner 4.0 →
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between the medicube Triple Collagen Toner - Hydrolyzed and the medicube TRIPLE COLLAGEN Toner 4.0?
The same collagen toner twice: 2,913 reviews of history versus a newer 4.0 with a wider skin-type brief.
Which is better, the medicube Triple Collagen Toner - Hydrolyzed or the medicube TRIPLE COLLAGEN Toner 4.0?
Neither is simply better; it depends on your skin and goal. Choose the original Triple Collagen Toner if hydration is the goal and you want the version with 2,913 reviews behind it. Choose the Triple Collagen Toner 4.0 if your skin is on the sensitive side or firmness is your main reason for buying.
Can I use the medicube Triple Collagen Toner - Hydrolyzed and the medicube TRIPLE COLLAGEN Toner 4.0 together?
Often yes. If they sit at different routine steps you can layer them lightest to heaviest, and if they do the same job you would usually pick one. Introduce new actives one at a time and patch test first.
Where these claims come from
- Star ratings and review counts: Amazon.co.uk's own figures for each listing, read on 2026-10-01.
- Prices and stock: read from each Amazon.co.uk listing, read on 2026-10-01.
- Best Sellers Rank and "bought in past month" badges: Amazon.co.uk's own figures, shown on the product page, read on 2026-10-01.
- Ingredient list as published by the manufacturer · medicube.us
We have not tested either product. Everything above is read from the listings and the manufacturer, with the dates shown, plus our own reading of what the two are for. Ratings are Amazon customers' scores, not ours.
Amazon.co.uk figures, not ours: prices read on 2026-10-01; star ratings and review counts read on 2026-10-01. Prices and ratings change; these are dated snapshots.
Prices move around, so always confirm on Amazon before deciding. Browse more options in Serums & Toners or browse the whole range.